Analog vs Digital: Does Mix Bus Processing Need Analog Gear for a Better Sound?

I wanted to recreate the master of the song Samanta – Alo, which I produced. You’ve done an amazing job with the master, but I’ve noticed something: when I try to emulate it with plugins, the song loses its vibe. However, when I use analog gear, it seems to hold together better.

My question is: Do you think mix bus processing truly requires some form of analog gear? Some engineers here say that analog is essential because the digital realm can make the sound feel more plastic.

I’d love to hear your opinion on this.

Thanks,
Apollo Producer